FAVORITE CASES IN THE STUDY OF CONSTITUTIONAL LAWYEAR = S VOLUME NUMBER 1961 = 1- 3 1962 = 4- 6 1963 = 7- 9 1964 = 10- 12 1965 = 13- 15 1966 = 16- 18 1967 = 19- 21 1968 = 22- 26 1969 = 27- 30 1970 = 31- 36 1971 = 37- 42 1972 = 43- 48 1973 = 49- 54 1974 = 55- 61 1975 = 62- 68 1976 = 69- 74 1977 = 75- 80 1978 = 81- 87 1979 = 88- 94 1980 = 95-101 1981 = 102-110 1982 = 111-119 1983 = 120-126 1984 = 127-133 1985 = 134-140 1986 = 141-146 1987 = 147-156 1988 = 157-168 1989 = 169-180 1990 = 181-194 1991 = 195-204 1992 = 205-216 1993 = 217-228 1994 = 229-239 1995 = 240-250 1996 = 251-265 1997 = 266-283 1998 = 284-300 1999 = 301-321 2000 = 322-348 2001 = 349-372 2002 = 373-394 2003 = 395-418 2004 = 419-447 2005 = 448-475 2 1903 = 3 1904 = 3.Philippine Reports YEAR = VOLUME NUMBER (Philippine Reports) 1901 = 1 1902 = 1.5 1905 = 5 1906 = 6 1907 = 7.9 1908 = 9-11 1909 = 13-14 1910 = 15-17 1911 = 18-20 1912 = 21-23 1913 = 24-26 1914 = 26-29 1915 = 29-33 1916 = 33-35 1917 = 35-37 1918 = 37-39 1919 = 39-40 1920 = 40-41 1921 = 41-42 1922 = 42-44 1923 = 44-45 1924 = 45-47 1925 = 47-48 1926 = 48-49 1927 = 49-51 1928 = 51-52 1929 = 52-54 1930 = 54-55 1931 = 55-57 1932 = 56-57 1933 = 57-59 1934 = 60-63 1935 = 63 1936 = 63 1937 = 64-65 1938 = 65-66 1939 = 67-69 1940 = 69-70 1941 = 71-73 1942 = 73-74 1943 = 74 1944 = 74 1945 = 74-75 1946 = 75-77 . 45459 Aglipay v. 64 Phil. Alba. 45358 Alvarez v. Dinglasan. R. 635 [1982V719] Anzaldo v. 33 [1956V99] G. 207 SCRA 713 [1937V43] G. CIR. 84 Phil. L-26400 Amigable v. 69 Phil. MOLE. 9 Phil. 101 Phil. No. 124 SCRA 494 [1940V77E] [1942v76] Ang Tibay v. No. No. L-37364 Aquino v. 386 [1972V45] G. v. 175 SCRA 343 [1907V136] Ayala de Roxas v. 89 SCRA 240 [1957V137] G. 201 [1945V19ECD] G. Herrera. L-8666 Amarga v. 127 SCRA 69 [1937V6] G. R. Clave. 124 SCRA 1 [1984V4] Almario v.. 75 Phil. R. L-41808 Amberti v. L-9637 American Bible Society v. 215 . City of Manila. Lazaro. L-2044 Araneta v. R. R. 63 SCRA 546 [1949V243E] G. City of Manila. No. CIR. Castro. Military Commission No. No. 151 SCRA 279 [1987V364] Alliance Gov’t Workers v. R. 126 SCRA 246 [1992V230] Adiong v. 2. 368 [1973V221] 1973-12-20 Asian Surety & Insurance Co. Secretary of Agrarian Reform. Cuenca. 54 SCRA 312 [1989V556] Association of Small Landsowners v. 43 SCRA 360 [1983V410] Anglo-Fil Trading Corp. No. Director of Prisons. 64 Phil. CA. Court of First Instance. 739 [1979V87] G. Inc. Abbas. R. L-6 Alcantara v.1947 = 78-79 1948 = 80-82 1949 = 82-85 1950 = 85-87 1951 = 88-90 1952 = 90-92 1953 = 92-94 1954 = 94-96 1955 = 96-98 1956 = 98-100 1957 = 100-103 1958 = 103-104 1959 = 105-106 1960 = 107-110 1961 = 111-113 1962 = 114-116 1963 = 117-119 1964 = 119-120 1965 = 121-122 1966 = 122-125 Constitutional Law Favorite Cases in the Study of Constitutional Law A [1983V582] Ablaza v. Ruiz. 98 Phil. 749 [1987R297E] Alih v. No. No. R. v. Commission on Elections. No. 119 SCRA 353 [1975V89E] G.R. L-50908 Bautista v. Fernandez. L-34243/ G. Nos. 77 SCRA 422 [1992v22E] G. R. No. No. R. No. R.[1988V353] Ayer Productions Pty. 152 [1954V1E] G. L-34038/ G. 94 Phil. L-61861 SCRA 383 [1929V150] G. Villanueva. Court of Appeals. Samson. R. L-75983 Cruz v. Judge Capulong. No. No. 108 Phil. No. Ericta. M. L-64261 Burgos v. No. R. No. R. R. Ltd. No. 53 Phil. 68566 Combate v. Roxas. R. 120 SCRA 15 [1967V343E] G. 102 Phil. Cruz. 37 Phil. No. L-6277 Crisologo v. R. San Jose. No. Director of Prisons. 121 SCRA 249 [1954V51E] G. Pabalan. 223 SCRA 761 [1985V145] G. 71 SCRA 356 [1993V545] G. 127 SCRA 329 [1984V141E] G. R. 570 [2001V491E] Bengson v. R. Valera. Inc. 39525/ G. Vivo. 133 SCRA 800 C [1957V263] G. 122 SCRA 759 [1934V117E] G. 71 SCRA 14 [1918V73] Banco Español v. R. 36376/ G. L-4003 Collector of Customs v. No. R. No. R. Castro. People. 205 SCRA 92 [1984V582E] G. No. Sandiganbayan. R. Chief of Staff. L-36706 Commissioner of Public Highways v. RCBC. No. L-18462 Bernandez v. No. 91927 Bunye v. L-5514 Calano v. No. Cruz. 160 SCRA 702 [1983V3] Cruz v. 128 61776 to No. No. R. House of Representative Electoral Tribunal. 42 Phil. No. R. 45 Phil. Nolting. 32025 Beltran v. L-16263 Cuyegkeng v. 702 [1998V832CD] Cojuangco v. 299 SCRA 744 [1983V266] City Gov’t of Quezon City v. v. Dimaano. 160 SCRA 861 [1984V515] G. R. No. 1147 D . R. Sandiganbayan. Mendoza. 20 SCRA 1123 [1960V29] G. 197 SCRA 853 [1977V176] G. Comelec. L-27206 Culanag v. L-52241 Azul v. R. L-45667 Borja v. 25 Phil. 8 Phil. R. Burgos. No. 94 Phil. Junio. 130716 Chavez v. R. R. 650 [1983V131] Cordero v. R. 96 SCRA 831 [1924V11] G. 357 SCRA 545 [1962V156E] G. R. Enrile. L-Bayot v. No. 7927 Barrameda v. L-24646 & L-24674 Callanta v. 96 SCRA 763 [1968V471E] G. 300 SCRA 367 [1976V171E] G. 230 [1977V171] G. 215 [1922V8E] G. De la Rosa. R. Villaluz. 24 SCRA 663 [1999R361E] G. 1120-MJ Baldoza v. L-29169 Chavez v. 133 SCRA 271 B [1983V59] Bagcal v. PSC. No. Flores. Rivera. No. 21741 Conde v. 17959 Clemonts v. 70 SCRA 477 [1980V55] Ceniza v. 921 [1913V87] G. R. Palanca. L-38688/ G. Sandiganbayan. Moir. R. 78631 Columbia Pictures. 39671 City of Manila v. PCGG. 135 SCRA 693 [1980V125] G. No. 125 SCRA 87 [1907v121] Cassanovas v. v. 77 SCRA 377 [1983V462] Caoile v. Villaraza. L-8974 Cabansag v. R. No. 44 [1984V33E] G. 4 SCRA 911 [1991V436ECD] Board of Commissioners v. 120 SCRA 525 [1976R136] A. No.No. Nos. 60 Phil. R. 125 [1976V122] Castro v. No. Hord. 477 [1988V323] G. Garcia. Board of Commissioners. 57883 De la Llana c. Quillen. R. 18619 Ganaway v. L-35707 Flores v. Court of Appeals. L-21362 DBP v. M. R. Tatad. No. L-56450 Ganzon v. of Education. No. 96 Phil. L-51773 De Guzman v. 135 SCRA 514 [1959v231E] G. The Sec. 123 SCRA 713 [1981V169] Garces v. 89572 Department of Education v. Estenzo. 95 SCRA 392 E [1993V169EC] G. 61 SCRA 331 [1979V188] G. 121 SCRA 472 [1988V162] Gaston v. Court of Appeals. R. No.[1968V678E] G. 115 SCRA 793 [1988V525] Gamboa v. 26 SCRA 366 [1989V1017] G. 77 Phil. R. 51 Phil. Division Superintendent of Schools of Cebu. 1993 [1998V700ED] Echegaray v. 57 Phil. 88265 Del Rosario v. No. 32 Phil. Barangan. R. 86 Phil. G. R. Bautista. R. Escalona. R. Alba. L-25769 Flores v. R. No. No. Ruiz. 769 SCRA 394 [1932V80E] G. No. No. City of Manila. No. No. 417 G [1986V309] Gaanan v. No. 95770 Ebralinag v. 255 [1987V176] Export Processing Zone Authority v. 180 SCRA 521 [1989V1017] G. 297 SCRA 754 [1967V306E] [1967V449E] G. 504 [1985V125] German v. Republic Planters Bank. People. Sandiganbayan. People’s Court. 145 SCRA 112 [1982V377] Gallego v. 162 SCRA 642 [1922V29] G. 805 [1983V349] G. 102786 De la Torre v. Enrile. 99 SCRA 514 [1977V275] A. R. 486 [1980V239] Fajardo v. R. San Diego. No. Stanley. L-52245 Dumlao v. 79 SCRA 61 [1974V458] G. Sandiganbayan. San Diego. No. R. No. Archbishop of Manila. Cruz. 288 SCRA 588 [2006V1395ECD] Estrada v. of Justice. Court of Appeals. Earnshaw. R. Presbitero. 461 [1998V523] G. 95770. Dulay. 36453 Evangelista v. R. No. L-982 De la Rama v. R. 20 SCRA 849 [1998V244] Espano v. L-3451 Gerardo v. 21 Phil. R. L-5917 Fonacier v. 8154 De Villata v. L-24693 Ermita-Malate Hotel and Motel Operators Association v. No. 106 Phil. Enage. 41 SCRA 3 [1982V96ECS] G. 104 SCRA 510 [1983V156] Garcia-Padilla v. No. Sec.. 89572 DECS v. 420 . 149 SCRA 305 F [1908V24] Fabie v. L-13954 Genaro v. R. 96 SCRA [1955V5E] G. No. 2 [1915V240] Gonzales v. 112 SCRA 294 [1946V164E] G. No. No. R. R. City of Manila. IAC. 294 SCRA 196 [1989V1018] G. R. 180 SCRA 533 [1980V181] G. 158 SCRA 621 [1991V438E] Gatchalian v. Bengzon. 42 Phil. 197 SCRA 854 [1950V166] G. No. CFI. 486-MJ Fernandez v. March 1. 180 SCRA 533 [1915V266] G. Inserto. 541 [1980V29] G. Comelec. No. R. 98 SCRA 619 [1971R290E] De la Camara v. 90 SCRA 429 [1980V115] Flores v. 250 SCRA 130 [1987V562E] [1990V411] Kimberly v. 280 SCRA 365 I [1996V457ESCD] Iglesia ni Cristo v. No. R. 148 SCRA 382 [2000V660] International School Alliance of Educators v. Textile Mills v.R. 19328 Katigbak v. Assn. Civil Service Commission. Nos. v. 128845. People. 78791 [1998V324] Knecht v. 567 [1997V594] Lalican v. Court of Appeals. 33973 Lansang v. 14 SCRA 292 [1983V296] Lobete v. 144 SCRA 194 [1979V95E] G. Morato. Comelec.No. Machuca. R. R. 360 SCRA 744 [1989V1033] G. 90 SCRA 16 [1985V419E] G. June 1 2000 J [1986V239] Javier v. No. No. No. R. Villaluz. G. 162 SCRA 840 [1997V787E] Ho v. L-2349 Harden v. De Villa. R. R. Santiago. 1928 In re Edillon. Liberty Flour Mills. L-33965/ G. Sotto Vda. No. NLRC. Garcia.M. Sundiam. De Gonzales. 89 SCRA 665 K [2001V664] Kapisanan ng mga Brodkaster sa Pilipinas. City of Manila. 82544 Harvey v. Director of Prisons. Nos. 58768-70 Liberty Flour Mills Emp. L-32066 Lagunzad v. 109 SCRA 87 [1965V202E] G. No. No. R. Blanco. Villaluz. 180 SCRA 668 [1981V440] Lirag v.[1980V456] Gonzales v. 150 SCRA 530 [1989V1049] G. G. 137 SCRA 717 [1990V79E] G. R. 39 Phil. 92 SCRA 476 [1919V12E] G. No. No. 276 SCRA 518 [1971V386E] G. Solicitor General. 180 SCRA 540 [1995R715E] Kilosbayan v. R. No. No.R. R. 21 SCRA 774. 297 SCRA 754 [1920V77] Kwong Sing v. 139 SCRA 349 [1970V144] Imbong v. 259 SCRA 529 [1979V146] G. L-46329-30 Joseph v. 741 [1988V549] G. 13307 La Insular v. No. 81 Phil. No. G. –A. L-19201 Lladoc v. 181 SCRA 623 [1971V28] G. Comelec. Court of Appeals. Commissioner of Internal Revenue. Comelec. L-33964/ G. 27 SCRA 835 [1985V301] Gonzales v. R. April 6. L-37527-52 Ignacio v. No. No. R. 41 Phil. 70748 Ilagan v. Katigbak. Quisumbing. 103 L [1979V293] G. 92-7-360-0. 80508 Guazon v. Director of Prisons. C. 1995 [1987R104] [1987R207E] In re Laureta. 84 SCRA 554 [1995V248ED] In re Jurado. Enrile. R.R. 35 SCRA 28 [1978R284E] A. Vergara. 42 SCRA 448 [1987V259] Legaspi v. 123 SCRA 95 . L-30026 Gumabon v. R. R. No. 37 SCRA 420 H [1948V192E] G. R. No. 150 SCRA 144 [1998V471ECD] Ople v. L-37051 Lorenzana v. 89 [1956V271E] G. L-32049 Mataas na Lupa Tenants Ass’n. v. v. 1 [1985V399] Nolasco v. 104 SCRA 1. R. No. R. 154 SCRA 542 [1938V197E] G. City of Manila. No. 127 SCRA 404 [1987V226] Olaguer v. Cayetano. CA. 1 [2003V628ECD] Macalintal v. No. 157083. R. 67 Phil. Ver. Comelec. R. Ople. 85 Phil. No. 80 Phil. R. 142 SCRA 149 [1989V747S] [1989V854] Marcos v. No. Paño. 99 Phil. 207 SCRA 1 [1987V561] Nestle Phils. 2 Phil. No. Araneta. No. Inc. Palacio. No. L-824 Moncado v. v.. 766 [1999V377E] Mercado v. 177 SCRA 669 [1983V354] Martin v. 91 Phil. 224 SCRA 792 [1968V90E] G. L-3580 Melo v. COMELEC. L-23794 Ormoc Sugar Co. L-439 Ocampo v. R. L-7859 Lutz v. 122 SCRA 405 [1984V264] G. Bernabe. L-62270 Malabanan v. July 10. Lopez Vito. No. 36 SCRA 228 N [1983V308] NHA v. 55 [1980V54] Occeña v. R. De la Rosa. 123 SCRA 245 [1992V161EC] National Press Club v. 45697 Manila Electric Co. Martinez. 146 SCRA 323 [1955V280] G. Dimayuga. Reyes. 20 SCRA 562 [1981V48] Morelos v. L-22196 Morano v.[1977V253] G. Flores. Ramento. R. 121 SCRA 538 [1967V252E] G. 129 SCRA 359 [1997V926E] Malacat v. Manzano. Comelec. No. 44142 Noble v. No. R. 22 SCRA 603 . Court of Appeals. 93 SCRA 503 [1970V211] G. Vivo. R. People. 307 SCRA 630 [1948V5] G. 80 Phil. 148 M [1947V33E] 1. 78 Phil. L-4221 Montenegro v. 120 SCRA 337 [1986V109] Lozano v. L-35861 Municipality of Daet v. Castañeda. Manglapus. 78 SCRA 485 [1983V35] Lozada v. v. No. R. R. No. Comelec. R. 130 SCRA 30 [1984V142] G. 111 SCRA 433 O [1946v128E] G. R. 128 SCRA 388 [1903V62] G. 74 [1950V78] G. Dames. Wolfe. 283 SCRA 189 [1939V291E] G. 2003 [1948V20] G. No. Bayona. R. Torres. No. L-50720 Mata v. 882 [1983V158] Morales v.R. L-1123 Mabanag v. 770 [1984V218E] G. No. 293 SCRA 141 [1993V623EC] Oposa v. Sanchez. 139 SCRA 152 [1990V445E] G. R. 1251 Mekin v. 102 SCRA 671 [1979V344] G.R. 738 [1986V78] Manotoc v. Yatco. Sandiganbayan. Corp. 1 [1952V178E] G. L-1486 Magoncia v. G. No. Comelec. 89317 Non v. v. 98 Phil. L-32717 Mutuc v. R. 77 Phil. Court of Appeals. 185 SCRA 523 [1982V39] Nuñez v. Factoran. R. L-9396 Manila Motors Co. No. Enrile. Treasurer of Ormoc City. Military Commission. People’s Court. 69 Phil. 95 SCRA 775. 123 SCRA 745 [1983V225] Marvel Bldg. v. No. No. 1128 (1945) . Cruz. 216 SCRA 101 [1980V402] People v. No. R. 269 SCRA 95 [1980V201] People v. Alde. March 31. R. Chan. Azura. Consulta. No. No. 45987 People v. G. Cayat. 99 SCRA 388 [1983V196] People v. R. 165 SCRA 47 [1939V147] G. Balisacan. Commission on Elections. 274 SCRA 238 [1983V476] People v. R. No. R. 65 Phil. Cabrera. L-25513 People v. No. Adil. of Education. Arciaga. 12 [1938V62] G. City Court of Manila. No. Capitin. No. Bardaje. 121 SCRA 637 [1976V354]G. 906 [1968V196E] G. 265 [1975V105E] G. 76 SCRA 462 [1939V317E] G. 22 SCRA 857 [1962V388E] G. 93 Phil. PBM. No. 97 Phil. 1991 [1992V938] People v. 51 SCRA 189 [2001V1367E] People v. Mago. G. R. 611 [1942V71] G. R. 221 SCRA 494 [1958V280E] G. No. No. L-41251 People v. 64 SCRA 224 [1997V168E] People v. R. 128222 People v. 69 Phil. 68 Phil. L-43790 People v. v. L-18733 Pareja v. No. 132231. Fajardo. City Court of Silay. L-5794 People v. 101 SCRA 86 [1987V274E] People v. Ching Kuan. 308 SCRA 432 [1983V161] People v. 23 [1999V420E] G. 94 SCRA 533 [1998V242ED] Osmeña v. No. Compil. Andan. No. Exala. 134 SCRA 362 [1988V737] People v. Estoista. R. No. No. L-5793 People v. Chua Ho San. 27360 Papa v. 22 SCRA 1299 [1980V134] People v. R. Cortez. 150 SCRA 653 [195 V208E] G. Dichoso. Sec. Bagasala. L-26376 People v. 104 Phil. R. Feati Bank. Court of Appeals. 70 SCRA 361 [1997V460E] People v. 244 SCRA 135 [1976V87] G. R. 136 SCRA 266 [1968V131E] G. 45435 People v. No. L-31041 People v. 122 SCRA 34 [1976V101] G. Fernandez. Crisologo.A.R. 288 SCRA 626 [1971V188E] People v.[1979V414E] G. 70 SCRA 277 [1994V671] [2000V1570] [2000V154] People v. Gomez. 21. Beriales. Oct. 443 [1938V61] People v. 99 SCRA 1 [1998V250] People v. L-40639 People v. 1998 P [1955V225] PACU v.R. Enage. No. R. Abino. 46551 People v. 806 [1985V174] Paderanga v. 74 Phil. Brecinio. Dramayo. 92 Phil. 92 Phil. 74 SCRA 30 [1985V40] People v. Bonola. L-39962 People v. 121 SCRA 228 [1973V87] 1973 June 05 PBM Employees Association v. L-21325 People v. Buscato. 372 SCRA 50 [1953V21E] People v. G. No. 96 SCRA 957 [1971V351E] G. C. Dionisio. No.R. R. R. R. 74 SCRA 248 [1995V292] People v. Court of First Instance of Rizal. L-12172 People v. 17 SCRA 1119 [1980V296] People v. Alarcon. 125 SCRA 182 [1976V329] G. 5 SCRA 823 [1983V129] Patanao v. Barros. 39 SCRA 236 [1966V389E] G. Ancierto. 48515 People v. 534 [1977V100] People v. 42 SCRA 59 [1953V233E] G. No. 92560. 674 [1993V353D] People v. R. Aruta. R. R. L-24670 Ortigas & Co. No. No. March 29. Perez. L-43672 People v. 122 SCRA 312 [1983V110] People v. No. 515 [1976V244E] G. R. R. L-33604/ G. 76 SCRA 81 [1924V136] People v. 124 SCRA 69 [1991V477ECD] People v. No.R. 63 SCRA 264 [1968V385E] G. 266 SCRA 607 [1998V407] People v. 121 SCRA 292 [1987V96] People v. 125 SCRA 269 [1983V532] People v. L-46542 People v. 45 SCRA 599 [1977V279] G. Regulacion. 129 SCRA 233 [1955V79] G. L-57738 People v. Jardin. No. 248 SCRA 679 [1977V25] G. R. Galano. Navarro. Marcos. 46 SCRA 88 [1992V355] People v. 84 SCRA 198 [1983V483] People v. R. Liwanag. Salico. No. Parazo. R. No. 1995 [1984V205E] G. Prieto. 198 SCRA 401 [1982V602] People v. L-27683 People v. 81 SCRA 453 [1986V161] People v. L-7491 People v. Relova. 141 SCRA 37 [1983V367] People v. 99 Phil. Ruiz. No. Salazar. No. 209 SCRA 179 [1983V226] People v. 84 Phil. Ortega. Malmstedt. 291 SCRA 715 [1949V298E] G. 1954 [1995V613] People v. 722 [1997V558] People v. 111 SCRA 515 [1994V706] People v. R. Nos. Lamsing. Opida. 132 SCRA 711 [1980V381] G. No. 23 SCRA 1249 [1986V92] People v. Ramirez. L-1567 People v. Magsi. Godoy. Pomar. 646 [1981V163] People v. 98 Phil. Ferrer. L-23572-76 People v. Macam. R. Gorospe. Obsania. Galit. L-33767 People v. No. L-24447 People v. 125 SCRA 734 [1976V23] G. R.No. 142 SCRA 295 [1997V565] People v. Ramos. Presiding Judge. Macaraeg. No. R. Figueroa. 98 SCRA 289 [1999R501E] People v. 69 SCRA 144 [1983V208] [1983V219] People v. Pablo. L-40633 People v.[1972V214] G. R. 117 SCRA 999. 276 SCRA 55 . 135 SCRA 465 [1955V157] G. No. 83 [1972V193] G. Lucero. Montes. R. 97 Phil. 276 SCRA 166 [1980V221] People v. L-7616 People v. Hondolero. Hernandez. No. R. Resano. Mencias. R. R. Lumague. 46 SCRA 440 [1978V238] G. 310 SCRA 146 [1986V363] People v. 73 SCRA 473 [1995V318] People v. No. 148 SCRA 292 [1984V478] G. 105 Phil. No. Go Pin. Mirantes. 238 SCRA 306 [1986V6] People v. Pilpa. No. L-30250 People v. 67 Phil. Pecardal. Livara. 124 SCRA 167 [1954V105E] People v. Salvatierra. Robles. Salas. L-30635-6 People v. Reyes. L-32613-14/ G. R. April 20. 143 SCRA 163 [1997V368] People v. 122 SCRA 409 [1983V169] People v. Quintal. R. 51513 People v. L-42925 People v. 1016 [1978V59] G. Saley. 248 SCRA 471 [1976v305] G. 48 SCRA 382 [1995V632] People v. 72 SCRA 422 [1983V377] People v. 75 SCRA 193 [1985V118] People v. No. 145 SCRA 674 [1974V131] People v. 418 [1995V228E] [1995V765E] People v. 244 SCRA 425 [1982V44] People v. 32613-14 People v. R. 129 SCRA 174 [1988V594] Philippine Association of Service Exporters v. Castellvi. Villareal. 244 SCRA 272 [1965V445E] G. R. R. 125 SCRA 115 [1981V504] People v. Provincial Board. L-64279 Pesigan v. No. Solis. R. R. L-21070/ G. No. L-1656 People v. R. Court of Appeals. R. 64 Phil. Angeles. 48 Phil. No. 239 SCRA 529 . 82 Phil. L-1800 Primicias v. R. R. 128 SCRA 217 [1997V65] People v. 52 SCRA 477 [1997V226ECD] PIRMA v. 21 1997 [1990V931E] G. Sarmiento. 101124 People v. No. Villanueva. 71 [1993V402] Province of Camarines Sur v. Villafuerte. R. R. 26 SCRA 620 [1994V614] [1994V798CD] Republic v. May 17.[1979V431] G. L-46833 People v. 1 SCRA 646 [1968V523E] G. 56 SCRA 219 [1983V467] People v. No. Veridiano. 241 [1974V281E] G. Poblete. R. 23051 People v. Serzo. No. Silva. No. People v. R. 168 SCRA 236 [1982V143] Perez v. Tabar. Benedictinos de Filipinas. 227 SCRA 703 [1995R305E] Philippine Press Institute v. 290 SCRA 595 [1925V98E] G. 58 SCRA 336 [1983V24] [1983V25] Republic v. Herida. 182 SCRA 601 [1980V109] People v. 274 SCRA 553 [1962V25E] G. 56 SCRA 219 [1973V125E] 1973 July 31 People v. R. Veloso. 132 SCRA 524 [1974V102] G.R. L-32037 People v. L-23326 PHILCONSA v. 73 Phil. R. Tac-an. 38443 People v. 41957 People v. No. No. No. 88404 PLDT v. 94 SCRA 944 [1980V265] People v. No. Seneris. 851 [1988V1019] Perez v. 113 SCRA 187 [1984V198] G. Villaluz. Tempongko. R. No. No. No. Fernandez. 529 [1933V175E] G. Comelec. 190 SCRA 717 [1983V603] Placer v. 45748 People v. 123 SCRA 327 [1937V87] G. L-21075 Republic v. R . Vilo. 15 SCRA 479 [1974V11] PHILCONSA v. Sandiganbayan. R. PLDT. 126 SCRA 463 [1987V417] Ponsica v. 1993 [1990V173] G. Villanueva. R. R. Court of Appeals. L-9141 Republic v. 99 Phil. Gimenez. No. R. L-15974 People v. Prado.21074/ G. Sunga. 99 SCRA 92 [1997V485] People v. Suarez. 163 SCRA 386 [1993V860E] Philippine Judges Association v. Drilon. Commission on Elections. No. L-12792 Republic v. 119 SCRA 411 [1961 Feb 28] G. No. R. Tampus. No. 169 [1939V34E] G. L. Tongko. 667 [1993V399] G. G. Sept. 198 SCRA 368 [1998V346] People v. Villafuerte. Vera. 4 SCRA 95 [1984V123E] G. 144 SCRA 583 [1991V475] People v. 222 SCRA 173 R [1941V250E] G. R. L-20620 Republic v. 65 Phil. 120 SCRA 154 [1956V303E] G. No. Fugoso. 56 [1984V463] G. Tiozon. Ignalaga. No. 267 SCRA 119 [1983V315] People v. 152 SCRA 647 [1948V23E] G. R. 934 [1982V728] Republic v. NTC. No. Sy Juco. No. 80 Phil. 47829 Ramos v. La Orden de PP. 110 SCRA 465 [1949V2E] G. 58 Phil. L-33957 People v. No. CFI. 129754. 96 SCRA 624 [1986V280] People v. Ylagan. L-62243 People v. Sec. L-37406 Tacas v. 200 SCRA 652 [1990V929E] G.R. Far East Broadcasting. 145 SCRA 687 [1996V155ESCD] Roberts v. R. 65 SCRA 336 [1983V581] Ruiz v. v. Paño. No. 67 SCRA 166 [1919V71] G. No. 152 SCRA 299 [1985V413E] Toyoto v. R. 80 Phil. 408 [1975V341E] A. 40 Phil. 270 SCRA 106 [1941V280E] G. CA. Court of Appeals. 146 SCRA 446 [1983V52] Tapales v. R. 369 SCRA 293 [1985V51] Salonga v. 175 SCRA 686 [1967V233E] G. No. 26 SCRA 286 T [1976V253] G. 20 SCRA 383 [1992V281] G. of Finance. Ramos. No. 1998 [1968V223E] G. Court of Appeals. 131 SCRA 184 [1989V588] SSS Employees Assn. 15574 Smith. Comelec. 81510 Salazar v. R. Martin. Ozaeta. No. 190 SCRA 686 [1983V488] Tan v. 119 SCRA 597 [1998V278E] TELEBAP v. R. No. R. Hontanosas. v. Achacoso. No. 48683 Santiago v. R. Sibonghanoy. 281 SCRA 330 [1982V552] Taxicab Operators of Metro Manila v. L-2509 Sura v. 93 Phil. No. 125 SCRA 553 [1986V368] Roan v. 120 SCRA 471 [1997V851ECD] Tatad v. Tuvera. Arca. R. Esteban. Sandiganbayan. Court of Appeals. 132992. 73 SCRA 333 [1989V683] G. Sandiganbayan. No. Commission on Elections. G. Villaluz. 176 SCRA 719 [1997V226ECD] Santiago v. R. R. 205 SCRA 605 [1948V54E] Subido v. Sandiganbayan. Sandiganbayan. v. 125 SCRA 697 [1971V325E] Tolentino v. BOT. 297-MJ Serafin v. 383 [1968V676E] G. Director of Forestry. 88050 Stronghold Insurance Co. 88 SCRA 811 [2001V1231] Sales v. 72 SCRA 528 [1987V128] Talino v. 139 SCRA 316 [1988V717] Twentieth (20th) Century Fox Film Corp.No. R. No. v. No. Cariaso. 71169 Sangalang v. 254 SCRA 307 [1983V72] Rodriguez v. Gonzales.[1983V517] Reyes v. 23 SCRA 29 [1983V528] Tio v. Bell & Co. 183 SCRA 145 [1979V12] G. of Energy. R. 120 SCRA 659 [1975V222] Roldan v. Natividad. Barrios. Nos. Court of Appeals. Sec. Mendoza. 235 SCRA 630 [1987V377] Tolentino v. L-49375 Salcedo v. L-3708 Rutter v. R. April 21. 164 SCRA 655 . IAC. Lindayag. No. 85481-82 Tan v. No. L-65952 Soriano v. L-19550 Stonehill v. 125 SCRA 302 [1986V430] Tañada v. M. 73 Phil. 126 SCRA 233 [1953V139E] G. Bagatsing. Commission on Election. 134 SCRA 438 [1976V302E] G. L-21450 Tijam v. Diokno. Gordon. L-44640 Sanidad v. Makasiar. Usman. 68 S [1990V224E] G. 148 SCRA 598 [1991V684E] Tampar v. R. 136 [1988V952] Soliven v. No. Comelec. 41 SCRA 715 [1994V526ECD] Tolentino v. 167 SCRA 393 [1984V352E] G. 676 [1912V99] U. 59 SCRA 54 [1920V19] Villaflor v. Court of Appeals.S. Toribio. 550 W Y [2001V560] Yap v.S. Kottinger. Garcia. Almeda. 45 Phil. 170 SCRA 256 [1989V782] Valmonte v. Javier. IAC. Espia. 70 Phil. v. v. 23 Phil. v.. Regala. 352 [1911V157] U. 731 [1910V145] U. Sandiganbayan. v. 284 SCRA 656 [1919V108] Visayan Refining Co. 94 SCRA 261 [1938V170] Zandueta v. Bustos. 141 [1987V134E] Ynot v. 86 SCRA 270 [1998V15] Vinta Maritime Co.S. Villegas.. Solis. 10 Phil. v.S. 41 Phil. 57 [1905V29] [1905V30] [1906V276] [1906V238] U. 97 SCRA 771 [1988V350E] [1988V859E] Zaldivar v. 15 Phil. Inc. Republic. 85 [1968V65E] Urtula v. 615 . Belmonte. 173 SCRA 211 [1983V62E] Velasco v. Pompeya. 40 Phil. 37 Phil. Inciong. 245 [1914V124] U. Poh Chi. 31 Phil.S. 37 Phil. 121 SCRA 444 [1985V147E] Villar v.S. 66 Phil. 7 Phil. 384 [1906V176] [1907V205] [1911V142] [1911V200] U. 22 SCRA 477 V [1989V123] Valmonte v. v. City Warden. Court of Appeals. NLRC. Elizalde Rope Workers Union. 62 [1983V154] Villar v. 358 SCRA 564 [1940V131] Yee Sue Koy v. 20 Phil. 120 SCRA 568 [1974V331E] Victoriano v. Technological Institute of the Phils.S.U [1907V48] U. 422 [1918V53] U. De la Costa. Summers. v. v. v. 506 [1905V251] [1905V234] U. 135 SCRA 706 [1978V412E] Villegas v.S. v. 6 Phil. 145 [1910V27] U. Camus.S. Tan Teng. 449 [1923V122] U. Hiu Chong Tsai Pao Ho. v. 28 Phil.S. 16 Phil. v.S.S. De Villa. 166 SCRA 316 [1979V20] Zambales Chromite v. v. 140 [1915V133] U. v. 148 SCRA 659 Z [1980V190] Zafra v. Apurado.